Film Review: Peter Chan’s The Road Not Taken Finds Life’s Unanswered Questions in the Fading World of Memory

With Zhou Xun delivering a layered portrayal of a woman losing her memory, Peter Chan turns an Alzheimer’s drama into a wider examination of fractured families, generational relationships and the choices that define a life. Rather than making illness the center of the story, the director explores what happens to the people who remain when memory begins to disappear.

LAPost/Film Review — By Richard Ren

There are films that tell us what happens in life, and others that make us reconsider how we have lived. Peter Ho-Sun Chan’s The Road Not Taken (明天,会更好) belongs to the latter category.

At first glance, the film appears to be a family drama about a middle-aged woman diagnosed with Alzheimer’s disease. But its ambitions extend beyond the medical and emotional consequences of memory loss. Through the deteriorating memory of its protagonist, Shen Jia, Chan examines the fragile architecture of family relationships, the distance between generations and the unresolved choices that continue to shape people long after those decisions have been made.

What makes the film particularly interesting is that Alzheimer’s is not simply its subject; it becomes the cinematic language through which the story is told.

When Memory Becomes the Narrative

The central challenge of making a film about Alzheimer’s is finding a way to represent an experience that is inherently subjective. Memory loss is not merely forgetting names, dates or familiar places. It gradually changes a person’s relationship with reality, identity and the people closest to them.

Chan approaches this challenge by moving the audience into Shen Jia’s perceptual world rather than observing her condition exclusively from the outside.

Scenes involving ordinary environments, including parking lots and markets, take on an altered quality through visual and sound treatments. Familiar surroundings become uncertain, while the boundary between past and present grows increasingly unstable.

This approach gives the film a perspective beyond conventional medical or family melodrama. Instead of relying entirely on dialogue to explain the protagonist’s condition, Chan uses cinematic expression to suggest the confusion and anxiety accompanying her declining memory.

The choice is significant. Alzheimer’s is often portrayed through the suffering of caregivers or the emotional burden placed on families. Chan shifts the center of attention toward the patient herself, asking audiences to consider what the world might look like when the memories that once gave it meaning begin to disappear.

The director has acknowledged that he cannot claim to know exactly how patients experience the disease. His approach grew partly from visits to care facilities and observations of patients confronting unfamiliar environments. That research informs the film without turning it into a clinical illustration.

Zhou Xun: A Performance Built on Emotional Transitions

The film’s success depends heavily on Zhou Xun, whose portrayal of Shen Jia requires a delicate balance between personality, vulnerability and psychological disorientation.

Rather than presenting the character simply as a victim of illness, Zhou gives her a recognizable individuality. Shen Jia is a woman with her own temperament, frustrations, relationships and history. Her difficulties with memory do not erase the complicated person she was before the diagnosis.

This distinction is important. A character defined only by illness risks becoming an object of sympathy rather than a fully developed human being. Zhou’s performance allows the audience to see both dimensions: the woman struggling to maintain control of her life and the patient gradually losing the ability to trust her own perceptions.

Her work is particularly relevant to the film’s treatment of family relationships. The changes in Shen Jia’s behavior expose tensions that existed long before the disease became apparent. Memory loss does not create every fracture in the family; in many ways, it makes existing fractures impossible to ignore.

Wang Xiao and the supporting cast contribute to the family dynamics surrounding the protagonist, giving the story a broader generational context.

A Family Drama Disguised as an Alzheimer’s Story

One of Chan’s more interesting creative decisions is to resist making the film a conventional issue-driven drama.

During the post-screening discussion at the Asian World Film Festival, he explained that he initially envisioned a marriage story before expanding the narrative to include relationships between parents and children and across three generations.

That evolution helps explain why the film is not exclusively about the progression of a disease. It is also about the complicated emotional arrangements that families construct over time.

There is often an assumption that family members naturally understand one another because they share a history. In reality, familiarity can produce its own form of distance. Old grievances, unspoken expectations and conflicting ideas about responsibility may remain unresolved for years.

When illness enters the picture, those tensions become more difficult to avoid.

Chan’s discussion of professional care facilities offers one of the film’s most consequential ideas. He recalled learning a principle from caregivers: “Go with the Flow.” Rather than constantly correcting patients when their perceptions no longer correspond to reality, family members should learn to accommodate their experience while recognizing when professional assistance is necessary.

For Chinese families, the decision to place elderly parents or loved ones in professional care can carry considerable emotional difficulty. Yet Chan raises a question that deserves more attention: Does caring for someone always mean personally assuming every responsibility, or can recognizing one’s limitations also be an expression of care?

This is where the film moves beyond an individual medical story and enters a broader discussion about aging, family responsibility and the changing nature of relationships.

The Meaning of Two Titles: Tomorrow and the Road Not Taken

Perhaps the film’s most revealing conceptual element lies in the relationship between its Chinese and English titles.

明天,会更好 (Tomorrow Will Be Better) suggests hope, continuity and the possibility of renewal. The Road Not Taken, inspired by Robert Frost’s celebrated poem, points toward the choices people make and the alternative lives they imagine they might have lived.

The two titles are not direct translations, but they complement one another.

One looks forward; the other looks backward.

Shen Jia’s deteriorating memory gives this contrast particular significance. As her ability to reconstruct the past gradually disappears, the audience is invited to consider how much of personal identity depends on remembering the choices that brought us to the present.

During the Q&A, Chan offered a perspective that is less optimistic than the Chinese title might initially suggest. He said he does not believe there is necessarily a right road in life. What matters is how one walks the road after choosing it.

That observation provides an important interpretive key to the film. The past cannot be rewritten, and the road not taken remains an imagined possibility. What people can do is confront the consequences of their decisions and determine how to live with them.

In this sense, the film’s two titles describe two sides of the same human condition: the desire to believe tomorrow can be better and the unavoidable tendency to wonder about yesterday.

Humor as a Counterpoint to Tragedy

Another notable aspect of the film is its willingness to allow humor into an otherwise serious narrative.

Chan said during the Q&A that the humorous moments were not deliberately constructed to balance the tragedy. They emerged naturally from the characters and situations.

He recalled being surprised by the laughter at a Toronto screening attended by approximately 1,700 people. The audience responded to the film almost as though it were a comedy at certain moments.

This mixture of laughter and sadness is more than a tonal device. It reflects the contradictions of everyday family life, where frustration, affection, embarrassment and tenderness frequently coexist.

A film about Alzheimer’s could easily become emotionally overwhelming if every scene were designed to reinforce the tragedy. By allowing ordinary human absurdities to remain part of the story, Chan gives the characters room to exist beyond their suffering.

The humor does not diminish the seriousness of the subject. Instead, it makes the emotional experience more recognizable.

Beyond the Disease: What Remains When Memory Fades?

Chan’s career has moved across genres and social landscapes, from Comrades, Almost a Love Story to The Warlords, American Dreams in China and Leap. His films have frequently examined individuals caught between personal aspirations and larger social or historical forces.

With The Road Not Taken, the scale becomes more intimate. The central conflict is no longer defined by historical upheaval or social ambition, but by the gradual disintegration of memory within an ordinary family.

The film is not without the demands of melodrama, and its emotional weight occasionally comes from the inherent tragedy of its subject. Yet its more lasting contribution lies in its attempt to see the disease from the patient’s perspective and to examine the family relationships surrounding that experience.

At its core, the film raises a question that extends well beyond Alzheimer’s: If memory is what connects us to our past, our identity and the people we love, what remains when that connection begins to disappear?

Perhaps the answer is not simply memory itself, but the relationships, experiences and traces we leave in the lives of others.

The road we take may not always be the one we imagined. The road we leave behind may never be fully understood. But, as Chan suggests, the meaning of a life is not determined solely by the choices made along the way. It is also found in how we continue to walk it.

That is the quiet question at the heart of The Road Not Taken—and the reason its story resonates beyond the screen.

Richard Ren is a senior journalist and film critic for The Los Angeles Post (LAPost.us), covering Chinese-language cinema, international film and cultural affairs in the Los Angeles area.