A Writer’s Odyssey 2 Review: Exploring the Creator’s Original Intentions and Obsessions Through Chinese Fantasy

By: Richard Ren, Critic / LAPost

October 01, 2025

On the evening of October 1, I attended the North American premiere of A Writer’s Odyssey 2 at the AMC theater in Monterey Park, hosted by CMC Pictures. Alongside a panel of Chinese experts from Los Angeles, I witnessed the unveiling of this long-awaited sequel. Director Lu Yang returned to the National Day holiday season with a more expansive worldview and more refined visual effects, not only addressing the controversies of the first film but also pushing the aesthetic boundaries of Chinese fantasy cinema.

Watching the film felt like falling into an Oriental fantasy dreamscape conjured by Lu Yang. Even in retrospect, its imagery remains vivid. The cast and visuals are stronger than in the first installment. While the special effects are grand and spectacular, many characters are also humorous and endearing, making the film well-suited for family viewing during the holiday season. More importantly, unlike earlier Chinese fantasy films whose effects often felt overly “Hollywoodized,” this time Lu Yang entrusted an all-Chinese production team, grounding the visual style firmly in Chinese aesthetics.

The film’s most striking feature is precisely this unique expression of Chinese aesthetics. Through a blend of practical sets and virtual technology, the domestic effects team constructed a fantastical world infused with Eastern philosophical thought. When the ethereal “Sky City” reveals itself, and the mythical “Five Tigers of the Sky” dazzle in battle, audiences finally glimpse the distinctly Chinese fantasy universe that has long existed in Lu Yang’s imagination. Locations such as Sky City, the Heart Tree, Dragonfall Plains, and the Primal Realm unfold like delicate Chinese paintings, with the ancient tree itself resembling something lifted from an ink wash scroll. The climactic action sequences—especially those of the “Red-Haired Demon” and the other tigers—push Oriental aesthetics to their peak. Their mystical techniques—spirit-channeling, invisibility, resurrection, devouring, and impenetrable stone armor—are dazzling to behold and clearly differentiate the film from Hollywood blockbusters.

This spectacle is not mere visual excess but intricately woven into the story. A Writer’s Odyssey 2 retains the core premise of “intertwining the novel world and the real world,” but shifts its narrative focus from an individual’s quest to find his daughter toward a more universal philosophical inquiry—“the meaning of life and the search for the self.” Through multiple characters’ dilemmas and choices, the film creates a dialectical space for varied answers. Compared to the first film, the link between reality and fiction feels tighter, with earlier narrative fractures repaired.

The motif of the father is particularly pronounced. Chang Chen’s portrayal of “Jiu Tian” is not only a spiritual guide to Lu Kongwen but also a symbol of traditional values and moral continuity. His presence elevates the story from a mere fantasy adventure to a meditation on values, particularly poignant in today’s context of “deconstructing patriarchy.” In contrast to the “success-at-all-costs” ethos embodied by the Red-Haired Demon, Jiu Tian emerges as a pillar of self-recognition and fidelity to one’s original purpose.

That said, the latter half of the film does exhibit some disjointed pacing and convoluted setups—such as the nested void realms and at times nonsensical interplay between reality and the fantastical—that invite accusations of being “overly adolescent.” Yet these narrative gaps may well reflect Lu Yang’s honesty as a creator. He does not placate the audience with a triumphant finale but instead reveals the novelist’s—and by extension, the director’s—hesitation and struggle between “defying fate” and “defending justice.”

Ultimately, A Writer’s Odyssey 2 does not provide a definitive answer. Its value lies in the stance it conveys: that amid the noise and uncertainty of our times, the creator still chooses to believe in writing, to believe in the meaning of expression itself. This stubborn honesty grants the film a rare balance between commercial appeal and artistic integrity.

If the first installment could be summarized as “to achieve is to believe,” then the second refines this to “to fight is to believe.” Action itself becomes meaning. Through this sequel, Lu Yang not only showcases the distinctive allure of Chinese aesthetics but also demonstrates the new heights Chinese cinema has reached in the fantasy genre.